Curse of the USP

//Curse of the USP

Curse of the USP

The author of this highly rated article is Ian Rheeder.
In 2003 Ian qualified as a Chartered Marketer (CM), the highest professional marketing qualification recognised both in South Africa and Europe.
If you want more valuable advice from this expert, click here.

The ultimate task of Marketing is to relevantly differentiate your company and its products from competitors. However, in search of differentiation, many of us select USPs haphazardly, sometimes being different just for the sake of being different.

“In order to be irreplaceable one must always be different.” said Coco Chanel, the French fashion designer & businesswoman (1883-1971). At the start of the feminism Coco pioneered pants for women and led the sun-tanning trend.

USPs should be CUSPs

Decades ago, when Philip Kotler modified UP (Unique Proposition) to USP (Unique Selling Proposition) he was addressing the same problem that still exists today! Marketers are choosing UPs that are not necessarily Unique Selling Propositions. An elegant solution to combat this common error is to adjust the USP acronym to CUSP (Competitive Unique Selling Proposition). CUSP is a distinct reminder that differentiation or uniqueness must lead to a pointed end – CA (Competitive Advantage).

In search of Competitive Advantage, too many marketers are also unaware of the hidden gifts in selecting competitive USPs. Very often, differentiation or CUSP opportunities are right under our noses – we just need to know where to sniff. By doing what their competitors do, but by doing it better, McDonald’s is very distinctive. You see, their Key Success Factors are convenience, consistency and value-for-money, and as boring as it sounds, are their CUSPs. McDonald’s focused, pre-emptive and synergistic strategic thrusts of ‘owning’ kids, makes them really distinctive.

Competitive Advantage

“If you don’t have a Competitive Advantage, don’t compete.” Jack Welch

In his book, Competitive Advantage, Michael Porter emphasizes that competitive advantage is what it’s all about, never even mentioning USPs, but rather referring to uniqueness as differentiation or distinctiveness, which leads to CA.

Low-cost and/or Differentiation: (See Diagram)

Low-cost production is an obvious method to seek out CA, however, only one company can really be the low-cost industry leader, which essentially is ‘differentiation’. Apart form the low-cost leader, all other players need to differentiate by attempting low-cost proximity (parity), but almost exclusively will have to rely on differentiation for their CA.

The curse of irrelevant USPs

Logically, to survive in a hypercompetitive environment, you will need difficult to imitate and relevant USPs; this would equate to a competitive CUSP or Sustainable Competitive Advantage (SCA). Lets look at five USPs which are not CUSPs:

  1. A beauty soap manufacturer decides to do a bit of market development, and enters the dishwashing liquid category with its excellent USP that works for the beauty soap category. “Now you can also moisturise your hands while doing the dishes.” Disaster. Why? Because Key For Success in washing dishes is cutting grime, not leaving a creamy residue over them. Secondly, by launching the dishwashing liquid as a ‘beauty’ brand-extension, it will reposition the beauty soap as a dishwashing liquid! Both categories would be hurt.
  2. A fast-food franchise, introduces the longest menu in the industry. Disaster. Why? Because Key for Success for fast-food is speed, availability of all ingredients, and consistency of flavour and service, which the extraordinary menu hindered.
  3. A beer is repositioned for a rave club market with a modern look-feel. Disaster. Why? Because Key for Success for a beer label is ‘heritage’, not a modern or contemporary look. (We drink with our minds not just our taste buds.)
  4. A light beer is differentiated using mud-wrestling babes in their TV campaign. Beer sales decrease. Why? Because image or ‘copy’ positioning was not a Key Success Factor to unlock their target segment. All they needed to do was mention that the product had less calories (CUSP).
  5. With the heavy road death-tolls, a car manufacturer becomes the first to throw in a free funeral policy – really making them unique!

Key Success Factors, a combination of internal and external drivers, are the very reason why all businesses are actually in business. A Marketer must first make sure all the Key Success Factors (KSFs) or points-of-parity are achieved for the category (competitive positioning), then brainstorm ‘differentiation’ or CUSP strategies, i.e. do what your targeted segment really needs, and then differentiate on being the best within the Key Success Factor range, and if you can add another CUSP, then that’s a bonus. If speed-of-delivery is a KSF in your industry, be different by being the fastest supplier – that does actually make you ‘unique’.

Diagram: CA is a by-product of Low Cost Leadership and/or Differentiation.Industry Structure & Key Success Factors (Competitive Positioning) play a major role

By | 2012-08-23T22:15:13+02:00 23rd August 2012|General|

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This